I've owned only one 1911 so my experience is limited. I have a Remington R1 and really like it. It's an excellent shooter and is accurate out of the box. I have had a lot of different handguns and I can say the R1 is fun to shoot. I finally had to start reloading .45ACPs so I can shoot it more often. I would not hesitate to recommend the R1. The best thing to do is try to shoot some of the different models and decide for yourself. There are other good 1911s out there.