BW, Sherriff or Earl?

[Anvil]

I've been contemplating a second firearm from NAA. I like the NAA-BWM-PVD Black Widow with the look of the unfluted cylinder and the mat black finish but I'm also kind of drawn to the 2.5" Sherriff and the 3" Earl. Both have the unfluted cylinders like the Widow and both are the same price and only $20 less than the BW. I've been told the Earl shoots more accurately but I personally think it depends on the ammo and how it digests separately in each individual gun. There's a gun show coming up in late June so I reckon if I see one of these it may be the deciding factor unless someone here can steer me to one in particular.
One thing I noticed is the sights appear much better on the Black Widow.

[gadget]

I have the silver BW with target sights and the 3? Earl. I like them both very much but I prefer the BW for the feel in my hand. The balance is different and the sights are much better but I like the looks of the Earl, so I carry both at the same time.

[OV-1D]

  All the "Earls" are fabulous for a first buy , easy straight shooters . Want to stay modern looking the BW is the other way to go .

[Rick_Jorgenson]

I've been contemplating a second firearm from NAA. I like the NAA-BWM-PVD Black Widow with the look of the unfluted cylinder and the mat black finish but I'm also kind of drawn to the 2.5" Sherriff and the 3" Earl. Both have the unfluted cylinders like the Widow and both are the same price and only $20 less than the BW. I've been told the Earl shoots more accurately but I personally think it depends on the ammo and how it digests separately in each individual gun. There's a gun show coming up in late June so I reckon if I see one of these it may be the deciding factor unless someone here can steer me to one in particular.
One thing I noticed is the sights appear much better on the Black Widow.

Anvil,

Truly the only way to know for sure is to get ALL THREE OF THEM   

The Black Widow is always a favorite, I do recommend owning at least 2 or 3 of them   

But the Sheriff and 3" Earl equipped with "Revision CV Grips" or,  NAA's "Boot Grips" are both great shooting guns!

The 3" Earl is a favorite "Kit Gun" or "Hiking Gun" for a few folks here on the Forum. One of the members here "Greyelke" has done some very accurate shooting with his 3" Earl. Maybe he will jump in here and confirm distance and target's he's hit with it.